12對史上最重要的喇叭

猜猜前三名是？

12 Klipschorn
http://www.avguide.com/sites/next-te...-klipshorn.jpg

11 MBL 101 E
http://www.avguide.com/sites/next-te...mbl-101e_s.jpg

10 Advent
http://www.avguide.com/sites/next-te...k-advent-2.jpg

9 KLH Model Nine
http://www.avguide.com/sites/next-te...peak-klh-9.jpg

8 Infinity IRS V
http://www.avguide.com/sites/next-te...nfinityirs.jpg

7 Magnepan 1-U/1-D
http://www.avguide.com/sites/next-te...agnepan-1d.jpg

6 Dahlquist DQ‑10
http://www.avguide.com/sites/next-te...quist-dq10.jpg

5 Magico Mini II
http://www.avguide.com/sites/next-te...agico-mini.jpg

4 Wilson Audio Tiny Tot (WATT)
http://www.avguide.com/sites/next-te...n-tiny-tot.jpg

http://www.avguide.com/review/the-12...l-time-tas-205

葉大，第4名的WATT貼錯了啦！還是說這是第三名的暗示:D

ㄚ..........放水了........

(1) 大家覺得有那些喇叭可以取代這些名單？

(2) 這十二對有實際看過、聽過的有那些？
我自己有5對，不到一半=> Klipschorn、MBL 101 E、Magico Mini II、Rogers/BBC LS3/5a、Acoustic Research AR3a

AR3a 這是每個玩音響都知道的[當年]

Infinity IRS V 絕對好[音、頻寬、音場]飽滿充實，縱使小音量聽也非常非常好聲

不少是歷史銘器..
應該少不了 tannoy 吧?

Tannoy那對比較有代表意義?

JBL也應該有的，如Hartsfield

JBL + Tannoy + Wilson?

引用:

---

作者: 小葉

Tannoy那對比較有代表意義?

JBL也應該有的，如Hartsfield

---

tannoy autograph

http://cyfa.co.kr/data/file/market_1...c7b4_z2---.jpg

應該15" silver

真是逸品呀...........

這個名單有不少遺珠之處
我認為除了好聲之外還要有技術的獨特性或是對其他廠家的影響
kLH9是好聲,不過既有Quad ESL入選,似乎沒有再選入它的必要?
先不講大型的JBL,altec,Tannoy
獨特的Heil ESS,Bose 901似乎都比幾個書架型揚聲器值得入選?
magico mini2獨特的地方是它非常貴嗎?

Magico入選理由，就是很厲害的意思

Certain speakers don’t just change the way the game is played; they change the playing field. In the twentieth century, the Quad ESL-57s (par excellence), the Maggie 1-Us, the Dahlquist DQ-10s, and the Wilson WATT/Puppy were bellwethers. In the new millennium there has been no more influential loudspeaker—no loudspeaker that has had a more profound effect on the way other loudspeaker manufacturers design and style their products—than these massive, beautiful, stand-mounted two-ways from upstarts Alon Wolf and Yair Tammam of Magico. The Mini and Mini II set new standards for neutrality, resolution, dynamic range, frequency extension, and musicality in compact speakers—and they did so not just by upping the ante on the way enclosures, drivers, and crossovers were built but also by upping the ante on the science that speaker manufacturers brought to bear on designing enclosures, drivers, and crossovers. Since the Mini II, birch-ply and aluminum boxes, high-tech composite cones, Mundorf parts, computer-assisted design have become mainstream—and other things like beryllium diaphragms, field-coil magnetics, and coincident drivers have been added to the mix. The competition in compact speakers has never been stiffer; nonetheless, the Magico Minis were the first on the ground and continue to more than hold their own against all comers.
Jonathan Valin

I believe JBL Paragon should be included. (inlove)
http://my-hiend.com/vbb/picture.php?...ictureid=11522
Also don't forget the coaxial design, Altec 604 serious or Tannoy Gold/silver (rofl)
http://my-hiend.com/vbb/picture.php?...ictureid=11519
http://my-hiend.com/vbb/picture.php?...ictureid=11521

almost forgot Lowther, Quad 57,:D

這種榜單不要太認真啦
這裡面我比較認同的只有
QUAD（平面單音路喇叭，承先啟後，包括他的專用低音也是非常有趣的設計）
W/P（相位跟箱體的傑出設計）
Khorn（背載號角，孔道式喇叭箱代表作）
MBL 101（無箱體360度的創意）
Infinity IRS（線音源的實踐，但是低音柱擺位很難兼顧頻響跟相位）

比較最近的設計中比較有趣的
我會推薦 Anthony Gallo Ref.3

http://www.desinformado.com/wp-conte...udspeakers.jpg

主要設計要點
1. 壓電柱型高音，不需分音器，可離軸聆聽不衰減
2. 金屬圓形密閉箱雙中音，無分音器
3. 側面低音，幾乎無箱，雙線圈，一個過分音器，一個沒有（要另加分音過的擴大機）
音場極大，動態誇張
可惜我聽到的音色不太理想，不過該音響店的專業素質極差
連喇叭線接法都是錯的

最有意義的，可能是票選十大音響聲學論文吧
喇叭設計的論文好像都離不開 Small, Thiel
好像 K 完就可以設計喇叭了 XDDDD

10. Advent 那一對我有, 老聲音好聽, 用Grundig的老AMP推實在是絕配啊

這期的TAS果然收到許多讀者迴響

說怎麼沒有這對、那對的.... :D

Dahlquist DQ‑10這對實在不應該列入，有抄襲ESL-57之嫌。（不過Dahlquist DQ‑10這對聽說聲音不錯）
另Rogers LS3/5a這對是新版的照片，應該不是推薦的原版本。

都很不错哦，只是不只怎么发不了帖